Amenities are a small cost per stay that adds up across a year of occupancy. The format decision matters more than the brand.
Mini bottles
Familiar to guests and easy to brand, but each stay uses new packaging and partly used bottles are thrown away. Some places now restrict small single-use toiletry bottles, so check local rules.
Dispensers
Higher upfront cost for the fittings, then lower cost per stay and much less waste. Choose tamper-resistant designs and a reliable refill routine.
Work it out per room night
Divide a month of amenity spend by occupied room nights for each option. That is the fair comparison. See supplywright.com/source/guest-amenities.